Organic Mascara
You should use an organic mascara if you have sensitive skin or eyes. It’s not only safer and gentler on your skin but less likely to cause allergies, especially since you will use on a daily basis. Organic mascaras are made with nourishing oils like argan which keep your eyes healthy. See our top 10 picks for 2024 below.
Top Benefits of Organic Mascara
1. Gentle on sensitive eyes: Organic mascaras is made with natural ingredients, making them a good choice for people with sensitive eyes or those who wear contact lenses. They tend to have fewer irritants, reducing the risk of redness, itching, or other adverse reactions.
2. Nourishing ingredients: Organic mascaras contain nourishing ingredients powered by mother nature, such as organic oils and plant extracts. These ingredients improve the overall health of your lashes and promote growth.
3. Safer for skin: Since organic mascaras are free of harmful chemicals and irritants, they are considered better for your long-term eye health. Using gentle, natural ingredients can help prevent irritation and other issues associated with prolonged use of conventional mascaras.
4. Environmentally friendly: Organic mascaras are made with eco-friendly ingredients, sourced from sustainable and ethically responsible methods. By choosing organic products, you are supporting environmentally conscious practices and reducing your ecological/carbon footprint.
5. Fewer allergens: Organic mascara formulas tend to have fewer allergens, making them a safer choice for people with allergies or skin sensitivities.
10 Best Organic Mascaras of 2024
Endlessly Beautiful Natural Organic Mascara
Ilia Fullest Volumizing Mascara
Poppy Austin Mascara, black
Ilia Limitless Lash Mascara, Black
Juice Beauty Ultra-Natural Mascara, Black
W3ll People Expressionist Pro Mascara
Fifth & Skin Naturlash Mineral Mascara, black or brown
Essence of Argan Lash Conditioner Mascara, Black
Physicians Formula Organic Wear All Natural Fake Out Mascara, Black
Harvest Natural Beauty Lengthening Organic Mascara
How To Choose an Organic Mascara
Ingredient Quality: Look for organic oils, waxes, and plant-based dyes that will enhance your lashes’ health and appearance. Also Vitamin E and other nutrients will nourish your eyes and keep them hydrated.
Color Range: While black is the standard color for mascara, you might be interested in brown for a softer look, or more adventurous colors like purple. It’s always useful to have black plus another color.
Wand Design: Bear in mind that each mascara has a slightly different wand which impacts the application and final look. Wands can differ in size, shape, and bristle design, affecting how the mascara applies and whether it’s designed more for lengthening, volumizing, or separating lashes.
Longevity and Smudge-Proof: A good mascara should be resilient, lasting throughout the day without smudging, flaking, or running.
Ease of Removal: While it should stay on all day, a good mascara should also be easy to remove without causing damage or excessive pulling on your lashes.
Sensitivity and Comfort: Choose a mascara that’s gentle if you have sensitive eyes, allergies or wear contact lenses. Most organic mascara is hypoallergenic and safe for your eyes but always check the ingredients.
Price: Organic mascaras are often a tad pricier than their non-organic counterparts but are worth the money as the quality makes up for the cost. We aim to recommend ones which are affordable.
Certification: Ensure the mascara is certified organic e.g. USDA organic, which confirms that the product meets recognized standards in organic production.
We care a lot about quality, organic products and realize there are some excellent products that are not on our lists however we do our best to pick from readily available suppliers and brands that can be purchased through many channels. All of our recommendations can be bought directly on Amazon in order to make it convenient for you and since they also have the best prices. Note that as an Amazon Associate we may earn from qualifying purchases Finally, all of our recommendations are based on our own experiences as well as recommendations from experts and reviews from other reputable sources. We have built our own model whereby we seek to find the best quality products at the value and best. We’ve been putting together shortlists for friends and family for years and so started the Organic Shortlist in order to help you save time searching for the best. We hope you find our shortlists useful!
